Review | The Silent Stars Go By

52857330. sy475

Book Information:

Series/Standalone – Standalone
Genre – Historical Fiction
Audience – Teenage/Young Adult
Page Count – 224
Date of Publication – 5th November 2020 by Andersen Press Ltd
Purchase – Waterstones | Hive | Book Depository | Wordery | Amazon

Book is mine and all thoughts and feelings are my own.


Seventeen-year-old Margot Allan was a respectable vicar’s daughter and madly in love with her fiance Harry. But when Harry was reported Missing in Action from the Western Front, and Margot realised she was expecting his child, there was only one solution she and her family could think of in order to keep that respectability. She gave up James, her baby son, to be adopted by her parents and brought up as her younger brother.

Now two years later the whole family is gathering at the Vicarage for Christmas. It’s heartbreaking for Margot being so close to James but unable to tell him who he really is. But on top of that, Harry is also back in the village. Released from captivity in Germany and recuperated from illness, he’s come home and wants answers. Why has Margot seemingly broken off their engagement and not replied to his letters? Margot knows she owes him an explanation. But can she really tell him the truth about James?


For a short and relatively quiet book, The Silent Stars Go By certainly packs a punch, not being afraid to tackle a myriad of feelings and heart-wrenching situations. In fact, I think it’s what Sally Nicholls seems to do best, exploring everyone in a story rather than solely focusing on those feelings of the main character. Yes, Margot’s journey is centre stage but she also tackles PTSD, depression, parental guilt, and worthiness within the Allan family, making the 1919 Christmas celebrations all the more poignant as they learn how to live in this temporary post-war world.

As a result, all the character arcs are open-ended. They leave us questioning what happens to them, and whilst I usually prefer some closure, it works in this case because life and time is too volatile. That also comes across in the writing as its very readable, easy style creates a sense of urgency. We want Margot to stop dancing round the truth and tell Harry about James, and to see them both reconcile before it is too late. However, at times it is a little too quick as we constantly jump back and forth from time to time in Margot’s mind. That volatility and urgency also creates a rather abrupt ending, which I think will surprise and possibly disorientate other readers, but at the same time highlight the situation.

I was a broken mess when I finished the book, and I still feel broken when I think about it now. It has also cemented Sally Nicholls as my favourite YA Historical Fiction author, and I’m excited to see what she comes out with next.

My Rating:

Rating: 4.5 out of 5.

Have you read The Silent Stars Go By?
What are your thoughts?

Published by Emma @ Turn Another Page

Hello, I’m Emma aka pageturner92, and welcome to my little corner of the online book world. When I don’t have my head in a book, I’m either working on an endless pile of crochet or knitting projects, playing Animal Crossing: New Horizons, listening to Disney music, or watching my favourite shows on repeat.

One thought on “Review | The Silent Stars Go By

  1. Oh wow this feels like it must really pack the punches in if it’s a short book because it sounds like it’s so emotionally charged! I love the sound of this one – thanks for sharing. Great review!

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: